Thursday, May 03, 2018

'Black Lightning' Fluctuates

Black Lightning is The CW’s newest TV series adaptation of a DC Comics property.  It’s not yet definite if the show is set in the main Arrowverse or in a different universe like Supergirl (likely, the latter).  Either way, its 13-episode debut season has proven that it’s not a redundant addition.  It brings something fresh.

Everything about the central character, Jefferson Pierce a.k.a. Black Lightning, is the best parts of the show.  Firstly, actor Cress Williams is suitably charismatic, that he almost has this Idris Elba-esque quality to his bearing on screen.  Secondly, the costume is pretty badass.  And thirdly, the presentation of his electric powers is fantastic.  In relation to this, they are excitingly incorporated and utilized in the fight scenes, yielding entertaining results.

Another thing that makes Black Lightning stand out is that he doesn’t belong in the same generation as his Arrowverse counterparts.  While Green Arrow, the Flash, Supergirl, and the Legends are in their 20’s or 30’s, Black Lightning is old enough to be their father.  As a middle-aged man, he’s dealing with the kinds of responsibilities, viewpoints, burdens, and imperfections inherently unknown to the younger DCW heroes.  For example, although he’s not washed up, he’s nevertheless being troubled by some depreciation.  Also, he’s the father of two young ladies, and though all DCW heroes carry a sense of responsibility (in varying extents), his has a distinctively paternal quality as a result.  Also, the show actually starts off with him retired as a superhero, and the first few episodes involve him contemplating whether he should un-retire or stay retired.  When all these unique character details are summed up, Black Lightning is given the projected air of a seasoned, august crime-fighter, which other DCW heroes don’t have.
The rest of the show’s characters are fine, I guess.  As necessary parts of the story, they do okay with their roles.  But I didn’t necessarily care so much of them as much as I get to care for the ensembles of other DCW shows.  That said, I like the family dynamics of the show’s narrative.  I like that Black Lightning’s sidekicks are his own daughters.  Well, at least, Anissa Pierce a.k.a. Thunder, who has already suited up in the first season.  The younger daughter, Jennifer Pierce, has manifested her powers, but hasn’t had a costume or superhero name yet.  But, most likely, she’ll eventually become Lightning (her comic book counterpart) in future seasons.

As for the writing, it shifts between being good and bad.  Sometimes, the narrative is enjoyably grounded and intriguing.  Sometimes, it’s boring and conventional.  And, just like other The CW shows, it has its share of SJW/liberal propaganda.  The show suffers when it touches on this, especially when it’s trying to have some political and social commentary.  Now, don’t get me wrong.  The attempt of commentary actually helps make the narrative more interesting at times, especially when it makes clever references or parallels to real-life events (e.g. US government experimenting on black Americans and flooding black neighborhoods with drugs).  On the other hand, there are also off-putting moments where it is obviously more concerned with its liberal agenda that it is even willing to make stupidly false equivalencies (e.g. the villain, who kidnaps kids off the streets to conduct deadly experiments on them, is painted as a Trump metaphor).
To sum it up, Black Lightning is a mixed bag for me.  Cress Williams’ Black Lightning is appealing, but his supporting cast is just basic.  I enjoy how the plot can get gritty, sensible, and down-to-earth in ways that other DCW shows can’t.  But its storytelling can’t maintain a constant thrilling and engaging quality.  Nevertheless, all in all, it’s a welcome new DCW show, and I can’t wait to see Black Lightning have a crossover with the other Arrowverse heroes (if he doesn’t, I will deem the show’s existence a failure).

So as far as being a rewarding black superhero TV show is concerned, Luke Cage remains the top dog.

No comments: